LogoLogo
  • Tally Docs
  • Tally Features
    • What is Tally?
    • Token Launch
      • Claim
      • Governance Smart Contracts
      • Token Wrapper
      • Delegate Registration & Claim-and-Delegate
    • Value Accrual with Staking
      • Features & Use Cases
      • FAQ
      • Glossary
    • Governance
      • Advanced Features
        • MultiGov
        • Advanced Voting
          • Flexible Voting Extension
          • Signal Voting
            • Snapshot
          • Private Voting
        • Partial Delegation
        • Security Council Elections
        • Chain Integration
        • Proposal Templates
        • Optimistic Governance
        • Gasless Voting and Delegation (Relay)
          • Gasless Voting
          • Gasless Delegation
        • Integrations
          • Karma - Delegate Scoring
          • Discourse
          • Safe
      • Standard Features
    • Tally API
    • Tally Zero
  • How to Use Tally
    • Navigate the Tally homepage
    • Set up a Tally Profile
    • Create Proposals
      • Custom Actions
        • Chain Deployment of Uniswap v3
        • Token Vesting with Hedgey
        • Token Grants with Hedgey
        • Streaming Payments with Sablier
        • Tuple Support
      • Swaps
        • Swaps: FAQs
      • Draft Proposals
      • Test Proposals
    • Execute Proposals
      • Advanced Execution
    • Delegate on Tally
      • Delegates Page
      • Delegate Voting Power
      • Create a Delegate Statement
    • Vote on Tally
    • Stake on Tally
    • Get Notifications on Tally
    • Use Tally with a Gnosis Safe
      • Vote with a Gnosis Safe
      • Zodiac Governor Module for SubDAOs and Grants Programs
      • Upgrade Gnosis Safe to Governor with Zodiac
    • Participate in Security Council Elections
    • Using Ledger with Solana
  • Set up & Technical Documentation
    • Tally Architecture
    • Deploy a Governor DAO
      • Deploy a Governor
        • Deploy a Governor with a new token
      • Add a Governor to an existing token
      • Check for Token Contract Compatibility
        • Network Support
        • OpenZeppelin Governor
        • Compound Governor Bravo
        • Tokens: ERC-20 and NFTs
      • Choose Governor parameters
    • Add a DAO to Tally
      • DAO Admins
      • DAO Settings
    • Use Governor with Gnosis Safe
      • Gnosis Safe Overview
      • Zodiac Governor Module for SubDAOs and Grants Programs
      • Upgrade Gnosis Safe to Governor with Zodiac
    • Staking Contracts
      • Get Started
      • How Staking Works
        • Liquid Staking
          • LST Auto delegates
      • Staking Operator's Guide
      • DeFi Integration Guide
      • FAQ & Troubleshooting
    • Security
    • Chain Compatibility
  • Education
    • Intro to Governance
      • General Ecosystem Info
      • Participating in Governance
    • Governance Concepts
      • Decentralized Governance Overview
      • Onchain vs Offchain Voting
      • Application Layer vs. Base Layer Governance
      • Governance Execution Methods
      • Procedural Governance
      • Vote Delegation
    • Governance Frameworks
      • OpenZeppelin Governor
      • Curve Voting Escrow
      • Multisigs
      • Snapshot Polls
    • DAO Best Practices
      • Running an Onchain DAO Using OpenZeppelin Governor
    • Index of DAOs
      • DAOs on Tally
        • Aave (AAVE)
        • Ampleforth (FORTH)
        • Arbitrum (ARB)
        • Compound (COMP)
        • Gitcoin (GTC)
        • GMX
        • Idle Finance (IDLE)
        • Inverse Finance (INV)
        • PoolTogether (POOL)
        • Uniswap (UNI)
        • ZKsync
      • DAOs Not on Tally
        • Balancer (BAL)
        • Curve (CRV)
        • Index Coop (INDEX)
        • KyberDAO (KNC)
        • MakerDAO (MKR)
        • Sushi (SUSHI)
  • Resources
    • Tally Platform
    • Blog
    • DAO Talk Podcast
    • Newsletter
    • Twitter / X
  • Payment Addresses
Powered by GitBook
On this page
  • What is Procedural Governance?
  • Protocols Using Procedural Governance:
  • Resources

Was this helpful?

Export as PDF
  1. Education
  2. Governance Concepts

Procedural Governance

Procedural governance refers to the processes, rules, and procedures that organizations follow to make decisions, implement policies, and ensure accountability.

PreviousGovernance Execution MethodsNextVote Delegation

Last updated 1 year ago

Was this helpful?

What is Procedural Governance?

Soft governance refers to processes, procedures, standards of conduct, and rituals of governance systems that are extrinsic to their onchain code deployment.

Many protocols have improvement proposal (IP) frameworks for ideating, discussing, and enacting key changes. While ecosystem actors will typically hew to these agreed norms to retain support of the wider community, the relevant updates can generally be made with a simple onchain vote even if the proposer didn't follow proper etiquette.

Protocols Using Procedural Governance:

  • MakerDAO

    • Weekly vote bundles

    • Maker Improvement Proposals (MIPs)

  • Uniswap

    • Suggested proposal process

MakerDAO has highly developed soft governance frameworks for curating weekly vote bundles and facilitating Maker Improvement Proposals. Elected facilitators play a key role in judging proposal coherence and validity via an offchain submission process, while series of non-binding poll votes determine whether specific initiatives can advance to a full onchain vote. These procedural norms have strong backing from the Maker community, but the core system will recognize MKR vote results regardless of adherence to these rules.

Uniswap published a suggested process for making governance proposals, from initial conception through to implementation. While any user with greater than 10 million UNI voting power is able to submit a proposal, Uniswap's soft governance procedure involves several preliminary polling and discussion steps to build consensus before calling an onchain vote.


Resources

MakerDAO MIP Process Overview
MakerDAO Weekly Governance Cycle
Uniswap Suggested Governance Process